Growing up in Michigan, I was a bit of a tomboy. I played with Matchbox Cars, collected baseball cards and Tigers’ autographs, and jumped at any chance to go to a Tigers’ game. In fact, I was obsessed with outfielder Kirk Gibson. And my obsession with him only grew after the Tigers won the World Series against the Padres in ‘84. 
The front page of the Detroit Free Press had a picture of Gibby celebrating the Tigers’ World Series win which was quickly made into a poster. And I, being Superfan Hilary, plastered these posters, along with an original newspaper copy, all over my bedroom walls.
The posters came with me when we moved to San Diego in 1985–the year after Detroit kicked San Diego’s butt in baseball. Since we* were hardcore fans, my family would often drive down to Anaheim to see the [then] California Angeles play the Tigers. My dad would make sure we got to the game early so he and I could hang out by the Tigers’ dugout to get my mitt signed. I had many of the ‘84 Tigers’ autographs and was dying to get Gibson’s. Here’s when it all went to hell. Pull out the tissues, because this is a tearjerker.
I was all decked out in my Tiger gear–hat, shirt, jacket, glove, you name it. Hanging out by the dugout, I had my mitt signed by some players, then saw Gibson. “Gibby, can I have your autograph?” I yelled to him. Here I was, a cute little 11-year-old girl, dressed head to toe in Tiger clothing. There was absolutely no mistaking I was a fan. I was so excited to think I would finally have Kirk Gibson’s autograph. As I got a pen and my glove ready for him to sign, he looked straight at me, said “No,” and walked away. I was stunned.
I cried. My dad yelled some not-so-nice things. Then we watched the game.
When we got home, I tore down my posters, ripped them up, and threw every Gibson-related item away. I guess you could say that was my first broken heart.
And of course, like any man in my life, Gibson reappeared a few years later, in the form of a Dodger. Of course he’d have to follow us out to southern California.
*Okay, my dad and I were fans. To this day, my mom will bring a book with her to a baseball game. And my sister will eat her way through it.